ISLAM (continua)
NIGERIA
In questa pagina
- Codice penale della Nigeria, art. 214
- Onu, febbraio 2005: Nigeria: Situation of homosexuals and their treatment under sharia
Nigeria, codice penale, articolo 214
.
Homosexuality remains a criminal offence under Nigeria's criminal code and can carry a jail term of 14 years while a sentence of death by stoning is the penalty under sharia law (BTM 13 May 2004; IRIN 7 May 2004; Sodomy Laws 8 May 2004).
Amnesty International's office in Bonn, Federal Republic of Germany, noted that "Nigeria's Criminal Code Act provides for severe penalties in dealing with same-sex acts performed between persons of the male gender," and provided the following excerpt from Chapter 21 of the Act, entitled "'Unnatural Offences'":
214. Any person who
has carnal knowledge of a person against the order of nature; or
has carnal knowledge of an animal; or
permits a male person to have carnal knowledge of him or her against the order of nature; shall be guilty of a felony and shall be punished with 14 years' imprisonment.
L'omosessualitā resta un reato penale ai sensi del codice penale della Nigeria e comporta la carerazione fino a 14 anni, mentre la condanna a morte tramite lapidazione č prevista dalla legge della sharia legge (BTM 13 maggio 2004; IRIN 7 maggio 2004; Sodomy laws 8 maggio 2004).
L'ufficio di Bonn, Repubblica federale di Germania, ha fatto notare che "la Nigeria del codice penale legge prevede sanzioni severe nei rapporti con persone dello stesso sesso fra maschi", e ha fornito il seguente estratto dal capitolo 21 della legge, Intitolato "Reati contro natura":
214. Qualsiasi persona che ha conoscenza carnale con una persona contro l'ordine della natura,
o con un animale,
o consente che una persona di sesso maschile abbia conoscenza carnale con lui o con lei contro l'ordine della natura,
č colpevole di un crimine e deve essere punita con 14 anni di reclusione.
Fonte: Commissione per l'immigrazione e lo stato di rifugiato del Canada (http://www.cisr-irb.gc.ca/):
Onu, Agenzia per i Rifugiati, Febbraio 2005
Nigeria:
Situation of homosexuals and their treatment under sharia (August 2004 –
February 2005)
This update of NGA42748.E of 14 July 2004 on the situation of homosexuals and
their treatment under sharia reviews publicly accessible information from August
2004 and February 2005. Although new information on legislation could not be
found, current reports on the enforcement of laws and state protection (Vanguard
28 Nov. 2004; ibid. 31 Oct. 2004; This Day 16 Jan. 2005; ibid. 28 Oct. 2004;
365Gay.com 29 Nov. 2004; HRW Sept. 2004), and societal attitudes (Sex Education
Apr. 2004; BTM 30 Sept. 2004; Daily Champion 20 Sept. 2004; EAS 2 Nov. 2004; ACN
2 Nov. 2004) were found among the sources consulted.
Enforcement of Laws and State Protection
Two sources reported that a sharia court in Keffi, Nasarawa State, had issued a
bench warrant against Mr. Michael Ifediora Nwokoma for allegedly engaging in
homosexual relations with Mallam Abdullahi Ibrahim (Vanguard 28 Nov. 2004;
365Gay.com 20 Nov. 2004). Nwokoma had reportedly escaped arrest, but Ibrahim was
detained by authorities (Vanguard 28 Nov. 2004). According to media reports,
neighbours accused the two men of "homosexualism," a crime punishable by stoning
under sharia, and handed Ibrahim to the authorities who nearly "lynched" him
while trying to force a confession (ibid.; 365Gay.com 20 Nov. 2004). The court
ruled that since the two must be tried together Ibrahim must remain in jail
until Nwokomah is arrested (ibid.).
In another story, This Day reported on the escape of Yusuf Tajudeen Olawale from
a jail in the northern state of Kano, where he had been awaiting trial for
allegedly having sex with another man (16 Jan. 2005). The news article explained
that Tajudeen, who had escaped from prison on 13 May 2004, had been added to the
wanted list by sharia state authorities, but remains in hiding (This Day 16 Jan.
2005).
A Human Rights Watch (HRW) report entitled "Political Shari'a"? Human Rights and
Islamic Law in Northern Nigeria, which examines sharia in the sphere of criminal
law as it is applied in the northern states of Nigeria, identifies specific
aspects of the legislation and practices that have led, or are likely to lead,
to violations of human rights (Sept. 2004). In the section on use of the death
penalty, HRW explains that various states classify homosexual relations as
sodomy, defined in their penal codes as the "carnal intercourse against the
order of nature with any man or woman," and, if convicted, a person faces the
penalty of death by stoning, by flogging, or by "any other means decided by the
state" (HRW Sept. 2004). HRW claims, however, that the study found no evidence
that anyone has ever been sentenced to death for sodomy with an adult (ibid).
Instead, HRW learned that "[i]n practice, most of the sodomy cases which have
come before the Shari'a courts have not been about consensual, sexual activity
between adults but rather allegations of adults sexually abusing children" (ibid).
In a January 2005 report, HRW reports that the number of sentences handed down
by sharia courts "has decreased and there appears to be a reluctance on the part
of the authorities to carry them out". While a number of people have been
sentenced to death, there have been no executions since early 2002 (HRW Jan.
2005). However, HRW claims express concern about the sharia courts lack of
respect for international standards for fair trials and due process "even as
defined by shari'a legislation; defendants rarely have access to a lawyer, are
not informed about their rights, and judges are poorly trained" (ibid).
Reports of the federal government's enforcement of the section of Nigeria's
criminal code that criminalizes homosexuality and calls for a jail term of 14
years upon conviction, could not be found among the sources consulted. In
correspondence to the Research Directorate, a representative of Alliance Rights
Nigeria (ARN), a non-governmental organization promoting the interests of
lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered persons in Nigeria (BTM n.d.), said
that the "Nigerian penal code is more strict on paper than [it is] practically"
(9 Feb. 2005). He further claimed that in Lagos, for example, gays and lesbians
can live freely as long as they do not impinge upon the rights of others (ARN 9
Feb. 2005). He cautioned, however, that gays and lesbians residing in Nigeria's
northern states are not as free since sharia is "more serious" (ibid.).
It is interesting to note the Nigerian president's comments on homosexuality and
same-sex marriages in a speech at the African Anglican Bishops Conference, held
in Lagos from 26 October to 1 November 2004 (Vanguard 31 Oct. 2004; This Day 28
Oct. 2004). Addressing more than 300 bishops, President Olusegun Obasango
reportedly stated:
I have followed, with keen interest, your principled stand against the totally
unacceptable tendency towards same-sex marriages and homosexual practice...such
a tendency is clearly unbiblical, unnatural and definitely unAfrican. Surely the
Lord who created us male and female knew exactly what he was doing. To my
understanding of the Scripture, any other form of sexual relationship is a
perversion of the divine order, and a sin" (Vanguard 31 Oct. 2004).
Societal Attitudes
Current evidence of Nigerian society's long-standing intolerance of
homosexuality (UPI 25 Feb. 2004; see also Religion in the News Fall 2003),
particularly among religious communities, was found among the sources consulted
(EAS 2 Nov. 2004; ACN 2 Nov. 2004; Vanguard 31 Oct. 2004; This Day 28 Oct. 2004;
Daily Champion 20 Sept. 2004; Sex Education Apr. 2004; ARN 9 Feb. 2005).
The Rt. Rev. Dr. Emmanuel Chukwuma, the bishop of Enugu diocese, announced to
the media that approximately 85 bishops of the Church of Nigeria (Anglican
Communion) had gathered for a four-day meeting in Enugu, chaired by the primate,
archbishop of the Church of Nigeria, The Most Rev. Dr. Peter Jasper Akinola, and
had "condemn[ed] homosexuality in its entirety" (Daily Champion 20 Sept. 2004).
Rev. Chukwuma reportedly stated that the Church of Nigeria would severe ties
with any of its member churches or affiliates who supported homosexuality
(ibid.).
Participants at the African Anglican Bishops Conference, mentioned earlier,
discussed ending their relationship with the Church of England over the issue of
the ordainment of gay clergy (EAS 2 Nov. 2004). Referring to the Church's
counterparts in the United States and Britain, primate Peter Akinola reportedly
said "[t]hey have a new theology and a new religion [and] we feel it would be
dangerous for the future of our church to continue to send our own future
leaders to those institutions" (ibid). According to the East African Standard,
the African church leadership would accept theological independence in order to
maintain its rejection of homosexuality and same-sex marriages (2 Nov. 2004).
Referring to homosexuality, the representative of ARN said that "[r]eligion is
the big problem here as priests/pastors and [i]mams talk about it as satanic" (9
Feb. 2005).
In a paper entitled Notions of Sex, Sexuality and Relationships Among Adolescent
Boys in Rural Southeastern Nigeria, Dr. C. Otutubikey Izugbara, a professor of
sociology and anthropology at the University of Uyo, presents the findings of an
in-depth study of 120 Igbo-speaking boys from the Ngwa ethnic group between the
ages of 10 and 21 (Sex Education Apr. 2004). Views on homosexuality were one
aspect of the study which dealt with images of sexuality and notions of
relationships with girls (ibid). According to Dr. Izugbara, when asked about
their knowledge of homosexuality, the participants agreed that the practice was
a perversion (ibid.). One 18-year-old reportedly said that he had heard "[m]ost
of the men and women who engage in this behaviour are witches and wizards"
(ibid.). Another boy, 19 years of age, commented that the church preaches about
the dangers of homosexual relations since the practice is "ungodly" and related
to witchcraft (ibid.). Izugbara concluded with the following statement:
Emerging results, though not conclusive or representative of the entire
population of adolescents in Nigeria, highlight a number of issues, which
support the notion of the cult of the male. This overarching aspect of gender
relations in many world cultures comprises a 'heady mixture of paternalism,
aggression, systematic subordination of women, fetishism of women's bodies,
idolization of male sexual capacity, and violence against women coupled with a
rejection of homosexuality' (ibid)
Despite what they viewed as African society's intolerance of homosexuality,
human rights organizations reported that two lesbians from Nigeria had attended
a meeting of the Coalition of African Lesbians (CAL), formerly known as the
African Lesbian Alliance (ALA), in Windhoek, Namibia, in August 2004 (IGLHRC 19
Nov. 2004; BTM 30 Sept. 2004). The Nigerian delegation, which included a member
of the Support Project in Nigeria (SPIN), an advocacy group for lesbians, gays,
bisexual and transgendered persons, and a representative of an organization
called the International Centre for Reproductive Health and Sexual Rights (INCREASE),
were among women from 14 African countries, including Sierra Leone, Ghana,
Liberia, Rwanda, Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania, Zimbabwe, Botswana, South Africa, and
Mozambique, who met to develop the vision, objectives and structure of the newly
formed organization (ibid; IGLHRC 19 Nov. 2004).
As well, the ARN representative wrote to the Research Directorate that gays and
lesbians regularly organize parties and frequent a "very gay friendly" night
club in Lagos (9 Feb. 2005).
This Response was prepared after researching publicly accessible information
currently available to the Research Directorate within time constraints. This
Response is not, and does not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any
particular claim for refugee protection. Please find below the list of
additional sources consulted in researching this Information Request.